KINDERCOMICS
  • Blog
  • About
  • Contact
  • Comics@CSUN
  • Comics Studies Society
  • KIRBY!

The Economic Clout of Children’s Comics

4/2/2018

0 Comments

 
Over the past two weeks, two of my favorite comic shops, Modern Myths in Northampton, Massachusetts, and Meltdown right here in Los Angeles, have announced that they are closing. News like this is becoming increasingly common these days, dovetailing with general news about America’s so-called retail apocalypse. Certainly the news coming out of the direct market, i.e. the specialized comic shop market, in 2017 was quite discouraging (see analysis and opinion here, here, here, and here). I’ve been a loyal direct market customer, and something of a historian of the market, for years (my first book, Alternative Comics, posits a likeness between comic shops and 18th and 19th century lending libraries, and suggests that shops, besides selling, also help to educate their clientele). I’ve seen upticks and downturns, crests and troughs, in the market again and again, and watched a number of beloved shops come and go; there’s always a fierce rate of attrition among comic shops, since the direct market is a bastion of independently-owned small businesses that tend to run on narrow margins. As Dan Gearino notes in his recent book Comic Shop, the direct market suffered in 2015, but bounced back somewhat in 2016 — this sort of dynamic is familiar. But this time, I must admit, things feel particularly dire to me; I worry that there will be no easy bounce-back, that indeed the direct market may indeed be at a discouraging pivot point.
Compounding this threatening downturn in the market, for me, is my own sense of alienation from what actually works in the direct market — a sense of weariness bordering on distaste. The best-selling comic in the direct market for the past few months (Doomsday Clock) is a project I dislike on its face, and, in my mind, confirmation of everything that is lame, inbred, and derivative about current superhero comics, which like it or not are the life’s blood of the DM. Further, there appears a serious disconnect between promisingly progressive books that sometimes move in the mainstream book trade and those comics that actually flourish in the direct market (cue here the ongoing discussion about the diversification, or not, of the DM). There is so much to cherish about comics today — in truth we are in a veritable Golden Age — but this does not seem to be borne out by most of what moves in the DM. As someone who loves comic shops and thinks that the historic and artistic importance of the direct market is still not fully appreciated, this saddens me.
But: the direct market is no longer the be-all and end-all of comics, of course. Comics retailer Brian Hibbs has been tracking and analyzing BookScan sales numbers for the past fifteen years (!), and his most recent analysis, published just last week at The Beat, gives a deep if inevitably partial view of how graphic books are selling outside of the direct market. (BookScan tracks much of the mainstream book trade, per Hibbs: “Barnes & Noble, Amazon, Costco, General Independents, ...Hudson Group, ...Follett Books, ...Powells, ...Sam’s Club and Walmart,” among others, but not comic shops, libraries, schools, and book clubs.) Hibbs charts the Top 750 items as reported by BookScan, and looks at both 2017 and the “long tail,” or deep continuing trends, for specific titles, creators, and publishers. It’s a long, careful piece — Hibbs is careful to note the methodological problems inherent in his analyses, and acknowledges where his data is incomplete — but here’s a couple of the takeaways:
Picture
HIBBS: Clearly, the first thing you can’t help but notice is that all twenty of the Top Twenty are books aimed at younger readers – it was just eighteen last year, and fifteen the year before. You have to hit #23 before you reach a book aimed at adults (“Persepolis”), #29 before you hit a book aimed at adults that could be considered DM-driven (“Saga” v7), and a staggering #36 before you reach something that that is a superhero comic (“Batman: The Killing Joke”). [...]
HIBBS: “Kids” comics is absolutely the hottest demographic of the moment, reminding me in any ways of pre-Direct Market times when comics were on the newsstands and the audience was assumed to turn over every several years. One difference between then and now is that when those kids turn over, [Dav] Pilkey and [Raina] Telegemeier and all of the rest of these authors will still be waiting for the next incoming group of kids because these are permanent formats, not transitory ones like periodicals were.”
It was precisely this sense of the growing importance of children’s comics that led me to launch KinderComics. Really, that’s why we’re here.
Now, this is not to say that the young reader's graphic novel market is entirely healthy and represents a future of smooth sailing for children's and young adult comics. That's not the gist of Hibbs's analysis. Sales outside of the direct market in 2017 were not so stellar as to justify unqualified celebration; print publishing in general does not seem so robust. Further, the DM remains an important conduit for much of comics culture in the US and Canada, so I continue to be concerned about its under-performance, persistent neglect of young readers, and increasing irrelevance or self-marginalization. However, Hibbs's report makes clear that the general book trade is where it's at when it comes to book-length comics for younger readers, and there are very strong sellers there. One cautionary sign in Hibbs's analysis is just how much of the Top Twenty (even more than the Top Twenty) consists of works by a few favored authors, such as Pilkey, Telgemeier, and Rachel Renée Russell — a lopsidedness that, I worry, may not bode well for the future.
Still, if further confirmation of the relevance and economic clout of children's comics were needed, I'd say that Hibbs's latest report gives that. This old direct market fan and collector is having to retrain his vision.
0 Comments

    Author

    See Hatfield, comics and children's culture scholar

    Archives

    January 2025
    December 2024
    July 2024
    June 2024
    May 2024
    March 2024
    June 2023
    February 2023
    December 2022
    July 2022
    April 2022
    January 2022
    December 2021
    September 2021
    August 2021
    June 2021
    May 2021
    January 2021
    December 2020
    November 2020
    October 2020
    August 2020
    July 2020
    June 2020
    March 2020
    February 2020
    January 2020
    December 2019
    November 2019
    October 2019
    August 2019
    July 2019
    March 2019
    December 2018
    November 2018
    October 2018
    July 2018
    June 2018
    May 2018
    April 2018
    March 2018
    February 2018

    Categories

    All
    392
    About KinderComics
    Abrams
    Adaptations
    ALA
    Animal Stories
    Anthologies
    Anti Sexism
    Anti-sexism
    Awards
    Best American Comics
    Bookshops
    BOOM! Studios
    Business
    CALA
    CalRBS
    CBLDF
    CCEL
    Children's Lit In Academia
    Class/Classism
    Collaborations
    Comic Con International
    Comic-Con International
    Comics As Social Protest
    Comic Shops
    Comics In Academia
    Comics Studies Society
    Comic Strips
    Courses
    COVID-19 Lockdown
    DC Comics
    Decade In Review
    Dial Books
    Disability
    Disney/Hyperion
    Drawn & Quarterly
    Early Readers
    Ecology
    EGL Awards
    Eisner Awards
    Essential Graphic Novels
    Ethics
    Eulogies
    Events
    Exhibitions
    Fairy Tales
    Fantagraphics
    Fantasy
    Faves
    First Second Books
    Flying Eye Books
    Folklore
    Food
    French BD
    Friendship
    FSG
    Gallery 13
    Graphic Medicine
    Grief
    Harper
    Historical Fiction
    History
    Holiday House
    House Of Anani Press
    How-to Books
    Immigrants' Stories
    Instructional Books
    International Comic Arts Forum
    Jen Wang
    JLG Selections
    LA Is A Comics Town
    LGBTQIA+
    Libraries
    Lion Forge
    Markets
    Marvel
    McDuffie Awards
    Memoir
    Middle Grade
    Miyazaki
    MLA
    Music
    Mysteries
    Nature
    News
    Nobrow
    Nonfiction
    Oni Press
    Paper Engineering
    Picture Books
    Poetry
    Politics
    Public Speaking
    Race/Racism
    Raina
    Random House
    Reading (and Watching) Hilda
    Reviews
    RH Graphic
    Sales
    Scholarly Works
    Scholastic/Graphix
    Schulz
    SF
    Simon & Schuster
    SOLRAD
    Sports
    Superheroes
    Teaching
    Teaching Roundtable 2018
    Textbooks
    Tillie Walden
    TOON
    TOON Books
    Top Shelf
    Tributes
    Updates
    Webcomics
    Witches
    Year In Review
    Yen Press
    Young Adult

    RSS Feed

Proudly powered by Weebly
  • Blog
  • About
  • Contact
  • Comics@CSUN
  • Comics Studies Society
  • KIRBY!